Sorry in advance, but this one is a bit of a rant. “Go Back Where You Came From” This seems to be the underlying sentiment and backbone of some philosophies trumped at and by us today. I am offended on a number of levels. Firstly, the correct English is “Go back to from whence you came.” So, if you don’t understand your own language, don’t shout it at strangers. My second level of offence is at the intolerance we show for each other at state level, and at every stratum of society, all the way to the most vulnerable. Thirdly, I am offended by the appropriation of the best culinary delights of numerous nations by those who believe the originators of those same recipes should “Go back where they came from.” I don’t go with this line of reasoning. I welcome diversity and I believe that we need to welcome the people as well as their recipes. So, when my Indian friend Prateek started a conversation about Indian cooking, I took the conversation to a logical conclusion and cooked these Indian Style Lamb Shanks.
Before I get any more offended (we are all now entitled to get offended by anything that appears on the Internet. It would appear that we are also allowed to be abusive and debased in our behaviour, while hiding under the cloak of anonymity worn by so many keyboard warriors), I really should give you the recipe.
Ingredients
- 4 lamb shanks (note that mine are hind shanks)
- 4 onions
- 500ml / 1 pint of good lamb, vegetable or chicken stock
- 400 gms (1 tin) of tinned tomatoes
- 150 gms of coconut cream
- 3 teaspoons of garam masala
- 2 teaspoons of green cardamom pods
- 2 teaspoons of black mustard seeds
- 10 to 12 curry leaves
- 1 teaspoon of turmeric
- 1 teaspoon of cayenne pepper
- 2 teaspoons of cumin seeds
- 6 to 8 cloves
- 1 decent sized piece of cinnamon bark
- 5cm/2″ of root ginger
- 4 to 6 cloves of garlic
- 1 teaspoon of salt
- 1 teaspoon of black pepper
Peel and pulp the ginger and garlic. Slice the onions into half rings. Heat a small amount of cooking oil in a casserole dish to medium hot and then add the mustard seeds. Stir them until they start to pop and jump about the place. Then add the onions and cook for a few minutes until they become translucent.
Add the pulped ginger and garlic. Stir this until it starts to darken and the aromas of onion, ginger and garlic cause your eyes to water. Then add in the shanks and stir to brown them a bit and cover them in the paste.
When the shanks get a bit browned around the edges, add the remaining ingredients. Needless to say, this presents me with the opportunity to try another pouring shot. The big shanks I used were almost impossible to turn in the casserole so they didn’t get as brown as I might have liked.
When all the ingredients are added, give them as good a stir as a packed casserole will allow. Then bring it to a gentle boil. Put a lid on the pot and place it in a 150ºC/300ºF oven. Leave it there for four hours.
After four hours, remove the casserole from the oven and remove the shanks. Reserve them on a dish in the oven. Strain the remaining sauce and reduce it until it is a nice thick and flavour packed pouring sauce. Take guidance from the picture below.
The shanks should be just about ready to fall apart at this stage.
Pour the sauce over the shanks and serve them. A handful of coriander doesn’t go astray at this stage. Serve the remaining sauce in a jug. You really can’t let it go to waste.
While you are enjoying this delight, reflect on the foreign people you may know. Think how dull your culinary life might be without lovely foods and flavours from around the world. While you are at it, think how dull the rest of your life might be without the rich influence of the people from the rest of the world. To my way of thinking, it leads to a logical conclusion. Enjoy.
John Boulton | 4th September 2019
|
An extremely good recipe, I’ve tried it – but being a genetic coriander-hater! I substitute with parsley. Incidentally the correct English would be “Go back from whence you came.” rather than “Go back to from whence you came.” just saying, you know.
Conor Bofin | Author | 4th September 2019
|
Hi John, many thanks for the comment and for the correction. However, I did my research on this and it would appear that both your and my versions are correct English. I had to pick one for expedience, knowing I might attract such comment. I have a good friend who is also a food blogger. She will be far more offended by my use of coriander than anything I say about foreigners. I believe distaste for it is genetic.
sallybr | 4th September 2019
|
cannot tell you how much I adored this post. Diversity is the spice of society. Period.
I have an accent. Most immigrants do, unless they embrace their new country when they are 10 years old, not my case. Having an accent immediately puts you in the threat of Go back to from whence you came – remark. It is tiring. Some ask where are you from with authentic, friendly curiosity. Some do it to shape their own reaction to the “foreigner in question” –
so thank you for the post and the wonderful recipe, and the amazing shots you do so well of spices falling in mid air…. I need to work on that!
Conor Bofin | Author | 4th September 2019
|
Thanks indeed for the kind words Sally. I live here in Ireland where we should be more tolerant of immigrants, given that we sent about a million of us abroad during ‘The Famine’. Sadly, we are not so, and I needed to call it out.
Stay well,
C
sallybr | 4th September 2019
|
My husband just spent a week traveling around Ireland playing golf with a buddy – he absolutely LOVED the country, the people, and want us to go back there together in the next year or so.
imagine? I could get to meet you in person… (well, assuming you would like to meet me… where do I get my ego???? 😉
Conor Bofin | Author | 4th September 2019
|
Sally,
I work with a US company who say in their recruitment materials “We leave our egos at the door”. Your mention of it tells me that this is how you are. When you are coming, it would (will) be an honor to cook for you.
Islay CORBEL | 4th September 2019
|
Well said and a delicious-looking recipe. Between trumptown and boris/Brexit we need a good dose of love and tolerance.
Conor Bofin | Author | 9th September 2019
|
Islay, you are so right. However, we can only do good in our own space. I know you are doing that.
Best,
Conor
katechiconi | 4th September 2019
|
One need look no further than the kitchen for the beneficial effects of ‘foreign’. All but three of your ingredients are non-native. Without the regular injection of said foreign, we’d still be eating gruel, pottage, oatcakes, beans, boiled mutton and other culinary delights.
And if we’re being picky about etymology, strictly speaking you don’t need ‘from’. Go back whence you came is sufficient, if unpleasant. I am fortunate never to have heard it in my own adopted land, especially around cricket and rugby time….
Conor Bofin | Author | 9th September 2019
|
I did my homework on the English used. Both versions are right, it would appear. We would be equally restricted if we didn’t embrace other cultures. I would be speaking Irish and eating fish, potatoes and little else. God bless the immigrants.
herschelian | 4th September 2019
|
I love lamb shanks, I also love Indian foods. It never occurred to me to put the two together. You are officially a food genius!! This is a recipe I will be making very soon. Thanks.
Conor Bofin | Author | 9th September 2019
|
Food genius might be stretching it. However, I’ll take the complement. You are too kind.
Eha | 5th September 2019
|
So much embodied here ! What you are doing in the world of cycling is exciting: we shall be here when you are finished !! When ever ! “Go back where you came from’ has been a well-known TV series here for a few years. I tend to pike out of watching as my BP has a tendency to spike . . . Sadly I have to admit that many of my youth time European university friends and I walk on different sides of the street these days . . . according to quite a few head-shaking ones I developed Alzheimer’s and ‘let the side down’ almost in my teens when ‘humanity’ entered my vocabulary . . . well, I sleep well at night !!! As for your lamb shank recipe – oh, you know I shall copy soonest and exactly !!! As I have said more than once I am delighted to see and learn from fusion recipes – like Stefan I do not accept that classic dishes can be changed willy-nilly and called by the same nomenclature . . . uhuh, am funny that way 🙂 !
Conor Bofin | Author | 9th September 2019
|
My eldest tried to buy an ‘eggs Benedict’ at Dublin airport. What was proffered was a slice of pan bread, a fried egg and some bacon on top. With this as a backdrop, I’m with Stefan!
Best,
Conor
Eha | 5th September 2019
|
. . . just checking late in the afternoon . . . thrilled to see Sally and Herschelian have come visiting . . . two of the ladies in the blogging world to whom I gladly bow my head . . . 🙂 !
Conor Bofin | Author | 9th September 2019
|
I likewise share your pleasure in seeing them here.
StefanGourmet | 5th September 2019
|
Great rant and great recipe. Agree with both.
I don’t remember — have you ever tried lamb shank sous vide? It is superb 48 hours at 62C.
Conor Bofin | Author | 9th September 2019
|
That gives me something to look forward to preparing. I have done them before but, I like to get a bit of encouragement to try them again. We are very lucky in the quality of the lamb we get here and I am particularly lucky to get great quality aft shanks every time.
sheila kiely | 6th September 2019
|
Ah the disappointing realisation that the number of morons in the world increases year on year. But let’s talk about the action shots instead. Hello, wow. But by number 2 you really were close to tripping into show-off territory. That mustard seed shot though, that needs to be entered into some competition and win a prize, it can’t just stay tucked up in the blog. You have inspired me to root out my camera and do a proper blog post again…. soon..(ish). and also to cook lamb shanks.
Conor Bofin | Author | 9th September 2019
|
Thanks Sheila,
I get disproportionate fun out of the flash photography that allows those ‘frozen in time’ shots. I really should share some more of them on Insta. However, the polaver required to get a DSLR shot onto the phone for sharing to the Gram makes it all seem to be too much work.
Our Growing Paynes | 6th September 2019
|
Such a great post. Telling people to go back is awful and to not even use their own language properly is even more galling. There is such a meanness in this world. On a nicer note, this looks amazing and I love the pour shots.
Conor Bofin | Author | 9th September 2019
|
Thanks Virginia. Kind words. We need more of them.
Frank Fariello | 8th September 2019
|
Can’t agree with you more, Conor. I’m saddened and enraged by the intolerance of (some) people here in the US, many of whom are themselves children or grandchildren of immigrants. Similar story in Italy, which like Ireland sent so many of their own abroad during tougher times. The hypocrisy is maddening.
In any event, on a happier note, the lamb shanks look delicious. I’ve been experimenting with Indian cookery lately, although I don’t have an Indian friend to guide me, only books unfortunately. The complex layering of flavors intrigues me. It’s very different from the Italian approach so it’s an interesting challenge.
Conor Bofin | Author | 9th September 2019
|
Hi Frank,
I really enjoy your Saturday emails with your posts. You have a great degree of regularity going there. I have fallen off the bus a bit. I need to get my act together. I appreciate your kind words and am delighted with the support I am getting from so many quarters for the concept outlined her (and for the shanks).
Best,
Conor
Eha | 9th September 2019
|
Frank – I hope you persist on a fascinating journey. As you may have gathered I am a European-born Australian who has lived in Australia most of my life. Two ‘curry-crazy’ husbands and decades later . . . go to ‘real’ Asian restaurants and ask questions ; remember that Sri Lanka, Bangladesh and Pakistan adjoin, read ‘real’ Indian cooks like Maddhur Jattrey for example, watch the latest Peter Kuruvita videos from Australia (Sri Lanka AND good!), try and be patient and read Conor who manages the layers just beautifully ! Yes, very different from Italian simplicity, but what a journey. Off topic: if you send me your email I’ll get that Mid-Eastern zucchini recipe to you 🙂 ! Conor: so sorry . . . . bestest . . . Eha