Mushroom and Beef Stew – Thank You Tim O’Brien.

Beef and Mushroom Stew (1 of 2)

We live in a rapidly polarising and intolerant world. More and more of us have no room to share with anybody who has different views, different religion, different nationality, different colour or different sexuality to ourselves. It’s kind of easy for me to take a stand on this as I don’t have a religion, have very few views on anything of importance, am a citizen of the world, in my underwear, I am a pasty colour that is best kept covered up and you can mind your own business on the sexuality bit.

Occasionally, right out of the blue, somebody does something nice, something that they don’t have to do. This sort of thing restores my faith in humanity. Tim O’Brien from Western Australia is such a person. Last week, Tim sent me an email saying some lovely things about the blog. He told me some funny stories of a trip to Ireland and generally made my life better. We need more of this from more people like Tim. If I am going to encourage these random acts of niceness, I had better cook up something really tasty. A Mushroom and Beef Stew fits the bill.


  • 5 trays of mushrooms. I used closed cap (medium and small), button, chestnut and portobello.
  • 1.5 kilo of shin beef
  • Extra shin bones
  • 1 litre of great beef stock
  • 1 large glass of red wine
  • About half a kilo of mirepoix (2 parts onion, 1 part carrot, one part celery)
  • 2 teaspoons of salt
  • 1 teaspoon of black pepper

Side note on mirepoix: There is always too much in a bag of carrots and in a celery plant to make a mirepoix for one stew or soup. Carrots and celery don’t keep well. My solution is to make a big mirepoix out of a bag of onions, bag of carrots and two celery plants. I break it into batches and freeze it. This is really handy for cutting down the prep time on soups and stews. 

The biggest job with this stew is preparing the mushrooms. They need to be peeled, cleaned chopped and cooked down.

There is a good half an hour in preparing the mushrooms. There is a lot of mushrooms.

While the mushrooms are being prepared you can brown the beef in a large casserole. Brown the beef in batches and reserve.

There is lots of stew flavour in the bones and in the marrow.

Add the mushrooms (there are lots of mushrooms) to the casserole. Add a very small bit of water to start the steaming process. Sweat them down for about twenty minutes, stirring to stop any burning or sticking.

Like I say, there are a lot of mushrooms.

The mushrooms will reduce and their flavours will concentrate in the process. Expect to see them shrink by about eighty percent.

Loads of flavour is concentrated in the mushrooms at this stage.

Add back the beef in layers.

Leave the bones in the stew.

Add the remaining ingredients and bring the stew to a gentle boil on the stovetop.

Having the mirepoix done in advance saves loads of time.

Place a lid on the casserole and pop it into the oven at 160ºC (320ºF) and leave it there for four hours. I used one of those hours to prepare a herbed polenta. This is easy to do. Simply make a thick polenta and add the herbs and salt and pepper, before it sets. Pour it into a cake tin lined with cling film and let it set. Cut it into triangles, roll it in polenta flour and fry until crispy.

Beef and Mushroom Stew (2 of 2)

The polenta is lovely with the stew. Try it.

This stew is really nice. Just like Tim’s email, it brings pleasure and restores one’s faith. So, I encourage you to do two things. Firstly, make this lovely stew. The mushrooms and beef work perfectly together and the polenta adds a delightful bit of crunch and herby flavour. Secondly, follow Tim’s example and do something nice for somebody who is not expecting it. You can help make the world a better place. At this stage, our world needs all the help it can get.

Written by
Latest comments
  • Good on you Tim! Being nice is the new cool! I love the idea of the polenta ( and the look of it, I mean come on!) as a side. There, I’ve done my bit too! 🙂

  • This looks so good. Great tip on freezing the mirepoix. And yes, everyone needs to be more kind and tolerant.

  • The mirepoix pre-prep is an excellent idea and I will steal it (yet again). The stew really does look wonderful…

  • This looks YUMMY. Off to the Butchers for my beef. Am I awful if I do this in my slow cooker? Thanks too for the Mirepoix tip. You’re a star.😘😘

  • Great minds think alike, I am making a beef, farro soup for my husband and will freeze it so he has something to eat when I am gone. He doesn’t like mushrooms, can you believe that? Thanks for this beautiful post.

  • This is one of my favorite dishes to make on a cold, dreary day, filling the house with lovely aromas! It sounds like this Tim O’Brien chap brightened your life indeed!

  • That looks so good 🙂

  • What a great tip on taking the time to make a heap of mirepoix and then glory for dishes to come! Had the beef been younger my mind would immediately have raced to my beloved osso buco but . . . seeing you used a whole five trays of mushrooms, Ireland must be as mean as Australia where size of s’market container is concerned 🙂 !

  • This looks like a lovely dish to have bubbling on the stove for the tail end of winter. Thanks for the share, and the encouragement of kindness.

  • Warm and fuzzy does sooo much good, no matter the source. Lovely recipe Conor, the perfect complement to kind words.

  • I’m with you on the tolerance bit. Don’t hate, treat people with kindness, do no harm. Seems pretty simple. Those mushrooms cooking look so good. I love stew like this.

  • Excellent, both the recipe and the sentiment. We need more niceness in the world. Lx

  • God (not that I believe in one) knows we could use more nice in this world. And more of that, which looks quite delicious.

  • I really must try your tip on making mirepoix in big batches and freezing it. I am constantly throwing out limp stalks of celery and discolored carrots, and even the occasional rotted onion. What a waste! But I wonder if the stay in the freezer doesn’t alter the taste and texture a bit?

  • So hearty and delicious!

Leave a Reply to anotherfoodieblogger Cancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: